Telling Stories with Maps – Where was Thomas Paine Born?

Today, the 4th of July, Americans celebrate Independence Day, the anniversary of the adoption of the United States Declaration of Independence.  To mark the day and join friends across the Atlantic in thier celebration, I present a story about Thomas Paine, the author of the influential political pamphlet, Common Sense, that stirred up the cause.

Click on the image to start the interactive map in a new tab.

Ready to place bets on the spot where Thomas Paine was born?  How close is the Thomas Paine Hotel?

Presentation of tangled ideas and webs of information is one of the challenges of genealogy.  A clear story is more likely to be understood and remembered by future generations.  The map above uses a sequence of images to organise bits of information into a sort of timeline.  Compare the same information presented without the ordering, using the ubiquitous Google maps.

Sumarising complex or large quantities of information involves compromise.  You just can’t put all the detail in and still have a clear story.  The maps above omit parts of the research that would benefit from visual presentation.  The parish boundaries of the 3 Thetford parishes wiggle through the town.  The northern end of White Hart Street lies in St Cuthbert’s and the rest of the street lies in St Peter’s.  The parish boundaries are marked on the Tithe maps, which can be viewed at the Norfolk Map Explorer, which date from around the 1840s.  This presentation overlays maps and aerial photographs.  Go and play with the layers and transparency sliders. Notice the changes in street layout.

An example of a fun presentation of map layers from different times is this map of 1836 New York. Can you spot a genealogical landmark (hint Castle Garden)?

New York 1836

Click on the image to start the interactive map in a new tab.

© Sue Adams 2014

Claverley Property Document Analysis, Part 3: Places

In the previous two parts of this series, I transcribed a manorial court record of a property transaction, and extracted information from it.  So far, I have only been concerned with information contained within the court session and cases.  The next steps are to check names, dates, places and legal language; and to identify people, locations and interpret events.  This process draws on information from other sources.

I’ll start with checking place names and locate them on a map.  The court records contained 11 names of places that referred to 7 specific locations, but stated the type of feature or jurisdiction (e.g. county, parish, dwelling house) in 5 instances.

A gazetteer (a geographic index, dictionary or encyclopaedia) is an ideal reference for validating place names.  A Vision of Britain is a key resource that includes historical gazetteers, boundary maps of many (but not all) jurisdictions, and tracks the history of jurisdictions.  It draws on two gazetteers, John Bartholomew’s Gazetteer of the British Isles (1887) and John Marius Wilson’s Imperial Gazetteer of England and Wales (1870-72).  The gazetteers include entries for 8 of the 11 place names, and the boundary maps include the parishes, district, and county.

Place name Type Gazetteer classification Location relative to Bridgnorth
Kings Arms dwelling house
Mill Hill property
Heathton township hamlet/ township 6.5 miles E
Hopstone unspecified hamlet/ township 4 or 4.5 miles E
Aston unspecified township 6 or 6.5 miles E
Catstree unspecified place/ township 3 miles NE
Draycott unspecified
Claverley manor
Claverley unspecified township and parish 5.25 miles E
Worfield parish village, parish and sub-district 3.5 miles NE
Bridgnorth unspecified municipal borough, town and district
Salop county ancient county

In only one case, the Kings Arms, the place name refers to a specific point, a building.  Hamlets and townships were small settlements, and villages and towns were larger settlements, all with no defined boundary. Jurisdictions such as parish, manor, borough, district and county were defined, and with the exception of manors are mapped by A Vision of Britain.  Examples are the boundary maps for the county of Salop, also known as Shropshire and the parish of Claverley.  Where the court document specifies a jurisdiction, we can be sure of the geographic area covered.

I did not find Draycott in the historical gazetteers.  The Vision of Britain boundary maps allows viewing of 4 map layers from different times.  Draycott is marked on the modern map layers (OpenStreetMap and Great Britain 20th Century) between Aston and Heathton.  The same hamlet is named Draycote on the Great Britain 19th Century layer.

Claverley – manor, parish, village

The court document referred to the manor of Claverley and Claverley as an unspecified entity.  The manor and parish were separate jurisdictions and usually did not cover the same geographical area.  There could be several manors within a parish and a manor could span the boundary of adjoining parishes.

Unlike parishes, manors have never been systematically mapped.  In the case of Claverley, I know of 3 documents that describe the manorial boundaries.  The earliest, dated 1509, is a metes and bounds survey written in Latin, which awaits transcription and translation (Shropshire Archives ref 5586/13/1).  The Manorial Documents Register includes two later boundary descriptions that I have not seen, dated 1615 and 1700-1900 (both at Shropshire Archives refs 1190/1/434 and 1190/1/433).

The court document references to the unspecified Claverley could be either the village or the parish.  Although the village doesn’t have clear boundaries, I think it does all lie within the parish from my interpretation of the maps.

The Kings Arms

Is there anyone who did not think ‘pub’ when you saw this name?  If not, I would guess you are not very familiar with Britain.

However, the court document explicitly refers to the venue as a dwelling house, a private residence, not a public house, a drinking establishment.  There is a pub called the Kings Arms in Claverley, but is this the same building?  A virtual wander in Google maps shows an historic looking building almost opposite the church.  The satellite view shows the pub is a large establishment comprised of several buildings joined together.

First we need to establish that the current building really is old enough to have been standing in 1844.  Fortunately, the Kings Arms is included in the English Heritage’s National Heritage List.  The listing describes the part a the building complex that includes the main entrance, and dates it to the 18th century.  So, yes it is old enough.

The Kings Arms name could have been applied to a different building in the past.  The tithe apportionments for Claverley, dated 1839, lists land owners and occupiers who were liable to pay tithes (a church tax) associated with property (Shropshire Archives ref 5586/5/19/1-3). Land parcel number 158 described as ‘Kings Arms Inn, Buildings & Yards’, was owned by William Smith and occupied by John Crowther senior.  I haven’t yet examined the tithe map to see where no. 158 is exactly.  I would not be at all surprised to find it is the location of the current pub.  When I have checked fourth source, the tithe map, as well as Google maps, listed buildings and tithe apportionments, I will be as sure as possible of the location of the Kings Arms, the building where the court baron was held.  That is not the same thing as my first thought of ‘pub’.

Mill Hill

The court record is all about the transfer of a piece of land called Mill Hill and associated house and out buildings, totalling 3 acres, 1 rod and 16 perches, but so far we do not know where that was.  The tithe apportionments give the following information:

Landowners Occupiers Nos. Refering to the Plan Name and Description of Lands and Premises State of Cultivation Acres Rods Perches
Felton’s Trustees, viz. John Wilson and Samuel Nicholls jun. William Ferrington 566 Waste and Land, before the House Pasture 0 1 15
588 House, Buildings and Garden 1 0 4
589 Mill Hill Meadow 1 3 37

The area of these three land parcels adds up to 3 acres, 1 rod and 16 perches (40 perches to the rod, 4 rods to the acre). The area, description, owners and occupiers all match the property described in the court record, so I am sure land parcels 566, 588 and 589 on the tithe map will show me exactly where the property was.  Umm, my excuse for not consulting the tithe map on my last visit to Shropshire Archives is looking feeble.  I could swear archive time is accelerated, honest!

In the meantime, I’ll pull together what I can.  Mill Hill was in Heathton township, which is somewhere near Heathton House, a listed building.  The manor of Claverley extended to parts of Heathton township.  The tithe apportionments confirm John Wilson’s ownership and occupation of Aston Hall, but possibly not the current building which dates from mid-late 19th century.

I have marked the places as points on the map below, but this fails to convey that most place names refer to a larger, undefined area (e.g. township) or a jurisdiction.  It is useful to see the spatial relationships between places.  The approximate directions and distances of places found in the gazetteers are confirmed on the map.

Did you think looking at a modern map was all you needed to confirm where your ancestors lived and did things like attending a court?

Next time I will examine the people involved in the court proceedings.

© Sue Adams 2013

A Blogging Achievement – 50 Marriage Mondays Completed

50 Marriage Mondays

How did I do?

I have achieved the publication of 50 marriages, 24 from Dad’s side and 26 from Mom’s side, listed in calendar order below.  The seed was planted when I was obsessing about the word count for my Masters degree thesis, which was supposed to be up to 16,000 words.  The total 50 Marriage Mondays word count comes to 30,788 ‘words’, but includes tables, captions and anything else WordPress blogging software thinks is a word.

Other objectives were:

Publish weekly

Close, I took a 4 week break between 25 March and 15 April, so these posts were published out of calendar order. One other post filled in a week when there was no marriage (30 July).  The publishing calendar was invaluable.  Now I need to make another one.

Cousin bait

Yes, some cousins made contact, but writing made me reconnect with people and make new contacts.

Putting the marriages into historical context and sharing a useful output.

I think I achieved this, do you?

Re-visiting my database, data verification, and properly recording sources.

Mixed progress.  The database still needs work.  I have found a lot of new information, but most has not been entered into the database.  I have been re-evaluating my research procedures and developing ideas about what genealogical software should really do.  Some material not included will be refined, expanded, and possibly submitted as a paper to FHISO.

  1. Stamp duty and authenticity of legal documents
  2. Citation and Verification or ‘Where the hell did I get this from?’
  3. Which Church? – Church and State Jurisdictions
  4. Hold the Front Page and 1960s Social Care of the Elderly
  5. Parish Register copies – Microfilm, Fiche, Transcripts, Abstracts and Indexes
  6. Parish Register Inconsistencies and Finding a lost website
  7. English Civil Registration Tools – FreeBMD, FamilySearch England Jurisdictions 1851, and A Vision of Britain
  8. Making the Connection between Civil Registration and Census Records
  9. A Wartime Wedding
  10. Of this parish – Residence requirements for marriage
  11. Online Search and Index Adventures with Ancestry and Findmypast
  12. Name change and Insurance
  13. Baptist Marriage and Birth records
  14. Civil Marriage and Witness Identification
  15. Is it George or Jack?  Engagement photograph identification
  16. A Boxing Day Marriage by Licence
  17. Marriage Banns and Putting Faces to Names
  18. Now you see it, now you don’t –  IGI and FamilySearch
  19. Following the Farmers – A Research Plan
  20. Representing Multiple Marriages and Crossing Connections
  21. Copies of Copies, Citation and Source Evaluation with FamilySearch
  22. Women in the Property Records of Clent Manor
  23. Common Surname Trouble – Adams in Birmingham
  24. Naming Patterns as Evidence of Kinship
  25. Vanishing Artifacts – the Gravestone and Silver Spoon
  26. Skipping Down the Generations – Ancestral Surname used as a Middle Name
  27. Marriage on Facebook and a Customised Chart
  28. The Girl Next Door? Local History, Maps and Back-to-Backs
  29. Evidence of Illiteracy among the Bargees of Britain’s Venice
  30. Who’s who?  Digital Photo Annotation
  31. Non-conformist Marriage by an Authorised Person
  32. The Housekeeper, the Valet and Grand Connections
  33. GRO Index Discrepancy or Name Variations?
  34. 20th Century sources – Electoral rolls, Google Maps and Land Registry
  35. Picking up the Tailor’s Thread through Trade Directories
  36. Provenance of a Personal Collection – Archival Accession, Arrangement and Description
  37. Linking the Jeweller’s chain through Trade Directories
  38. Is a Rare Surname easy to find?  Searching for Barrowclift with Ancestry and FindMyPast
  39. Keeping it in the Family?
  40. Religious Affiliation and Who’s the mom?
  41. Pieces of Evidence – Corroborating a Family Tale
  42. Wills and Location – Further Evidence supporting the Inherited Family History
  43. Engagement Evidence – The Diamond Ring
  44. The Wife’s Whisper – Indirect Evidence from the Manorial Court
  45. Postcard Correspondence with In-laws
  46. Housing and Economic Status
  47. Cousins  and a Golden Wedding Anniversary
  48. Death, Divorce or Desertion?
  49. Isa and Charlie – Double Tragedy
  50. The School Master and Seed Cake

© Sue Adams 2013


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 808 other followers